Oh, don't get me started on the pathogen! They are leaving Earth, but bringing the plants with them - and that means they would bring this pathogen as well, so what's the point?
Suicide is a reasonable hypothesis, but he was also sending a robot there, clearly expecting it to survive. And getting an information via 5th dimension is OK, but don't tell me he EXPECTED it to work this way. He doesn't seem to be psychic.
As for oxygen: he is a freaking astronaut! If he makes some calculation and declares that they can do that, but only in the last minute - that would be OK. I don't need to see that calculation, but I want at least an order to the robot to do it!
And no, I didn't really sympathize the characters (with the exception of young Murphy: that girl was really cute), and that's not what I expect from Nolan. I expect a cool story - and the story was quite troublesome.
no subject
Date: 2014-11-17 11:28 am (UTC)Suicide is a reasonable hypothesis, but he was also sending a robot there, clearly expecting it to survive. And getting an information via 5th dimension is OK, but don't tell me he EXPECTED it to work this way. He doesn't seem to be psychic.
As for oxygen: he is a freaking astronaut! If he makes some calculation and declares that they can do that, but only in the last minute - that would be OK. I don't need to see that calculation, but I want at least an order to the robot to do it!
And no, I didn't really sympathize the characters (with the exception of young Murphy: that girl was really cute), and that's not what I expect from Nolan. I expect a cool story - and the story was quite troublesome.